Microfinance – 40 years on

Tandi asked a great question so I thought I would make a posting of my response rather than burying it in comments. A word of warning, I am no expert on microfinance, or Bangladesh.  The following is based on a number of conversations I have had in the past month.  The interesting thing is I am spending a day with a microfinance team from BRAC on Thursday, out in the field where the practical work is done.  Should be a great experience, and also interesting to keep in mind the comments I have heard from mostly academics and researchers from the devloping world, who do not necessarily get their hands dirty in the trenches.

Microfinance 40 years on – the primary aim all those years ago was to give people access to credit to lift them out of poverty and make them self-sufficient. The talk here is it has not really done that. Why?

The women keep coming back for additional small loans once the previous loan is paid off. They get into a cycle of debt akin to credit card debt that we see in the developed world. The husbands continue to take the cash the women get as loans, leaving the woman with the debt and no way to earn money to pay it back. She then may be forced to go to another institution to get a loan, to repay the initial loan. Or worse still, go back to the moneylender who charges higher interest rates but whose loan is ‘off the record’ and therefore blind to the microfinance institutions.

So in effect she is credit surfing which puts her in a worse rather than better position. Women being women, they pay back the loan hell or high water but it can be to the detriment of the wellbeing of the family.

The thinking here is, better to set up co-operatives, buy communal equipment (crafts, farming, fishing etc) for the extended community to use so that the whole community can benefit …. including the men who are “good” yet who are not supported because most of the aid programs are directed towards women. The tables have turned on gender discrimination it seems. Food for thought.  But much more to come.

About Kate Coffey

After 25+ years in the investment management industry, I packed in my job and spent 2014 living and working in Nepal and Bangladesh, and visited some other places in between. It took me on a journey I did not expect, had me fall in love with Nepal and it's people, and become inspired at the work of Spinal Injury Rehabilitation Centre (SIRC) located 2 hours east of Kathmandu in the Sanga foothills. Since 2014, I have continued my warm relationship with SIRC and worked closely with my friends there in the aftermath of the 2015 earthquakes to date. This blog initially started out as a travelogue of sorts to keep friends and family worldwide updated while I was off on my travels in 2014. Since then it has morphed into a life story of the many places I have lived and worked and of the wonderful people I have met along the way. I hope you enjoy.
This entry was posted in Bangladesh and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Microfinance – 40 years on

  1. Tandi says:

    Very interesting Kate. What an unexpected twist on the initial vision.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s